Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Small World
by Laura Zigman
challenging
emotional
sad
tense
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This was such an intensely conflicting book for me. The first half, I would give two stars, but then the second half with the character development and tension with the neighbours, more nuanced flashbacks, ramped it up to four stars. But as a whole, not my favourite.
Small World is about two sisters deciding to live together post-divorce after years apart. The main character, Joyce, spends her time working to archive memories for other families and doing weird stuff like photoshopping safety equipment into the background of their old photos. Her only hobby is perusing an online community board called Small World and turning the posts into found poems. She and her sister do not relate or barely even communicate with each other and through flashback we realize they’ve been traumatized by the seeming neglect from a mother who was preoccupied with their disabled sister and advocacy work on her behalf.
They had a dad who could have been parenting them too but eh who cares.
It’s really hard to live in Joyce’s POV for the first half, she’s such a whiner, woe is me I don’t get as much attention, I just wanted to shake her. As a mother of a developmentally disabled child myself I found it really hard to stomach her vilification of her mother for what seems to be a woman just trying her best. This was a real growth as a reader kind of situation for me to grow to understand her perspective and enjoy the book despite my emotional visceral reaction to it. So, I’m saying it could just be me and my personal reaction, that might not affect other readers in the same way, I don’t know.
Other issues I had with this book was the switch from first to second person narration in the flashbacks. I HATE second person narration I find it so distracting and annoying, so it took a long time to get over that too.
Finally the found poems… just eeesh. There was a lot about this book that wasn’t my cup of tea, but I did end up enjoying it in the end and I thought the ending was beautifully well done.
I was really looking forward to this read, so that may have made it even more disappointing that it didn’t live up to my expectations. Also, I don’t think the synopsis and description of it is as accurate as it could be.
Probably wouldn’t recommend.
Small World is about two sisters deciding to live together post-divorce after years apart. The main character, Joyce, spends her time working to archive memories for other families and doing weird stuff like photoshopping safety equipment into the background of their old photos. Her only hobby is perusing an online community board called Small World and turning the posts into found poems. She and her sister do not relate or barely even communicate with each other and through flashback we realize they’ve been traumatized by the seeming neglect from a mother who was preoccupied with their disabled sister and advocacy work on her behalf.
They had a dad who could have been parenting them too but eh who cares.
It’s really hard to live in Joyce’s POV for the first half, she’s such a whiner, woe is me I don’t get as much attention, I just wanted to shake her. As a mother of a developmentally disabled child myself I found it really hard to stomach her vilification of her mother for what seems to be a woman just trying her best. This was a real growth as a reader kind of situation for me to grow to understand her perspective and enjoy the book despite my emotional visceral reaction to it. So, I’m saying it could just be me and my personal reaction, that might not affect other readers in the same way, I don’t know.
Other issues I had with this book was the switch from first to second person narration in the flashbacks. I HATE second person narration I find it so distracting and annoying, so it took a long time to get over that too.
Finally the found poems… just eeesh. There was a lot about this book that wasn’t my cup of tea, but I did end up enjoying it in the end and I thought the ending was beautifully well done.
I was really looking forward to this read, so that may have made it even more disappointing that it didn’t live up to my expectations. Also, I don’t think the synopsis and description of it is as accurate as it could be.
Probably wouldn’t recommend.