This was a reread for me (I listened to the audiobook), and it didn't hold up as well as My Sister's Keeper did. I loved this so much the first time I read it, and now it was okay, but nothing special. I did enjoy it, but I found so many more flaws this time. A lot of things rubbed me the wrong way and I disliked more of the characters (including Jack). The very end seemed more for shock value than anything else. I did still like it, but I was disappointed that I didn't like it as much as I remember.