birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Consent by Jill Ciment
4.0
reflective

Hmm. It’s hard to know exactly how to feel about this short but impactful memoir. 

Jill Ciment reflects on her marriage to a much older artist she met when she was sixteen and he was 47, married with two kids her age. This is her second memoir about her life and relationship, written with a new perspective, post Me-Too and without the collaboration and gaze of her husband reading her reflections and editing her version of events.

On the one hand it feels overly indulgent to write two memoirs about the same thing, and not come away with something concrete and convincing. The name of the book is Consent but it doesn’t feel like she really tackles the theme. 

Ciment wonders if there was anything darker or sick lurking in the story of her “seduction” of him but hangs her narrative on the free-love of the 70s and her own rebellious and independent spirit, painting a love story that’s main issue isn’t in the unbalanced element of power but in whether she can stomach his physical body aging and societal judgement, which she can, easily, and they have a happy 45-year marriage until he dies in his 90s. 

And yet, it feels like we’re still hearing all this from the perspective of the teenager who refuses to admit there’s a problem at all. Almost as if her ability to really interrogate this relationship arrested at the age they met. She keeps asking questions—was he grooming her, was he preying on a fatherless girl, was he a succubus feeding off her youth and vitality…but she doesn’t really answer these, only seems to turn away—dismissive. The idea that a seventeen year old, not fully grown, without a wholly developed brain could be the driver of this relationship honestly just feels a little silly to me. The answer feels obvious and the way she wants to explain it away just really sad. 

I feel like this is a common view of that generation’s inability to see these May-December relationships as problematic as they are. 

The scene where she talks about her little brother’s abuse and the way the police react to realizing she’s with husband not her mother—feels like the closest she comes to a kind of realization but then it’s over.

I dunno. Very compelling read, lots to think about.