birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

The Nature of Witches by Rachel Griffin
2.5
lighthearted slow-paced

I was ready to love this book, but unfortunately it felt incredibly repetitive—the world building was minimal—and the plot consisted of basically one long training montage. 

I feel like the idea of seasonal witches (I’m probably a winter) and an environmental crisis effecting them all was a really interesting idea for what amounts to just another book about a school for magic. I liked the descriptions of magic and the idea of an Ever witch who can harness the power of all seasons, but there just wasn’t enough actual world building for me—we never see anything outside of the school really so it’s difficult to feel all that invested in the struggle.

There’s a very dear romance at the heart of the book—and I do agree that Sang is one of the best YA love interests I’ve read in awhile. He’s a gentle Spring witch who loves botany which is just so nice to see in contrast to the many toxic male main characters usually peppered into books. So that was the saving grace for me. But, about halfway through I just started losing interest. The writing became just constant reiteration of the same thoughts and feelings and I didn’t feel invested at all.

Cute idea, sweet romance, but ultimately a bit of a let down for me plot and story-wise. I’m kinda sad about it honestly.