cjeanne99's profile picture

cjeanne99 's review for:

The Lost Girls of Paris by Pam Jenoff
4.0
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Based on the story of the women who served in Britain’s Special Operations unit in World War II - women who were trained in the basics of espionage and then dropped into France to help support the Allies. In Post WWII New York City, Grace Healy finds a suitcase sitting under a bench in Grand Central Station. For some unknown reason - other than - it helps with the plot - Grace opens the suitcase, finds an envelope of pictures, takes the pictures and leaves the suitcase. She then learns that a woman was hit by a car near Grand Central - and pieces together that the suitcase belonged to the dead woman. Grace goes to the British Consulate in NYC to ask questions about the woman - and runs into roadblocks. 
In the meantime - we go back four years to London - and learn of the work of Eleanor Trigg - who is recruiting and training an elite group of women to serve as radio dispatchers, couriers and saboteurs in France. Eleanor trains them well - and begins to suspect that something is wrong with the transmissions of some of the girls. She brings her suspicions to the department head who dismisses her. 
Things go terribly wrong in Paris - many of the operatives are arrested, the leader is killed. Marie , one of Eleanor’s girls, is on a train transport being sent to a German POW camp along with four others form her group. AFter the war, Eleanor is sent to France to try to uncover what happened to “her girls”. She follows a trail that leads her back to her own department - and her boss - to determine the source of the betrayal of her operatives. 
Grace is also searching for answers about the girls in the pictures. With the help of her dead husband’s college friend - she gains access to State Department files in Washington DC - and starts to unravel the mystery. 
As I reflect on the book - I wonder why Jenoff chose to have the dual timelines of Grace in NYC and Eleanor in London - the girls in France. Couldn’t she have told the story just as well by just focusing on Eleanor and the girls? What value is brought to the book by including Grace Healy? Grace who sees a suitcase that appears to be abandoned - opens it - takes the photos - and leaves the suitcase. Who would do that?