rafdee13's profile picture

rafdee13 's review for:

The Immortalists by Chloe Benjamin
2.25
adventurous dark mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

The writing itself was fine. The characters were great in the beginning, you got a real sense of being a kid in the summer, goofing of with your siblings and hearing about the possibilities of magic everywhere. But once they become adults that magic leaves. Each "part" of the book follows one of the four siblings. It's structured reminded me of the "what remains of Edith finch" game.

Simon's is the first. It starts well, but stumbles over
the weirdest descirption of a vagina ive ever heard
and
simon expressing his desire for a massive dick. Im listening to the audiobook version at work and my face kept screwing up out of laughter. The line "his cock was so red it was almost purple" won't leave my brain, help.
Simon's sole characteristics as time goes in being that he's
gay
and horny. You figure out what will happen to him pretty quick, and instead of tragedy it's just...kinda blank face "okay, sure."

The way people of color are treated uh..I Mean they are there, and they checkmate the Gold family on their privilege and assumptions. But idk how much of that is actual character, or as a heavy handed reality check for the reader and white protagonists. 

The argument between
Raj and Daniel
is especially full of this. At least those Identities are addressed. The Romani throughout this book are also in a precarious position between sympathy, hatred, usage of their slurs by one and all, and historical interpretation. I'm not sure how I feel about their portrayal. Leaning toward Not Great. 

All in all, this book was interesting as an experiment but didn't quite live up to the premise, and falters from some frankly bizarre additions to the story.