I think I rated it a 5 star when I first read it, but I did change that rating now. because I enjoyed it and it such a good book that is not only fantasy but also mysterious. but something felt missing this time something I can not quite catch. but sometimes reading is just a feeling. I did love to return to this world and I did not notice that this took place during winter (because there is snow in the book) but I am so happy and sad at the same time that this is over. I will continue the series maybe next month but we will see