Like a warm hug from your grandparents (the ones you like) - The Fellowship of Puzzlemakers is a heartwarming, cozy read about not just finding answers, but finding yourself along the way. The characters were charming, unique, and made me miss my grandma in the best way. While this has a mystery element, do not go into it expecting fast-paced, hard hitting clues and discoveries - instead, this is much more a gentle exploration of the characters, where you'll probably guess the mystery before the ending, but not in a disappointing way. 

The dual-POV between Clayton and Pippa was done so well - multiple POVs (especially with dual-timelines) can be challenging, usually leaving the reader wanting more of one than the other - but this was not the case here thankfully. I enjoyed both POVs and timelines immensely and I think really opened up the story and characters. 

The one thing I wish we got to see was more of was Clayton growing up and his interactions with the residents/members of the Fellowship. I absolutely adored the small bits we got to see between him and Earl and I found myself wanting more of that.