I was tricked. I have to admit that I picked up this book because I saw it on the new releases shelf at the library and its cover was beautiful. Unfortunately, the story was just annoying. Told from a then/now perspective of Heather, we get to see her as both an adult and a preteen. The ‘then’ passages were cringey and filled with teen angst and the ‘now’ passages were filled with paranoia. Heather was unlikable (not in a Gone Girl-esque way) and I only finished this book because I could not find spoilers online and it would’ve bugged me not knowing what happened at the end. Blah.