I really had to think about what to rate this one, as I found myself caught between a 2 and a 3, so 2.5 felt like the right spot. The concept of the story is intriguing, and I loved the atmosphere, which set the stage perfectly for some good mystery and folk tales. Unfortunately, the execution didn't quite live up to its potential.

For much of the book, not a whole lot happens. It meanders into lengthy descriptions and interactions that didn't seem to add much to the overall experience. Then, out of nowhere, the pace picks up towards the end, making me wish the whole book had maintained that level of intensity and engagement.

It feels like the story could have benefited from some serious editing—trimming down the excess and focusing more on the eerie setting and core plot. There's so much potential here, and it's a shame it didn't quite come together in the way I was hoping.

Overall, Pine had the bones of a great tale, but it left me wanting more in terms of substance and suspense.