cjeanne99's profile picture

cjeanne99 's review for:

Only the Beautiful by Susan Meissner
2.75
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character

Lots of mixed feelings about this book. I rarely like narratives that alternate between two timelines - which was especially annoying with Roseanne’s story as the “flashbacks” were from not that long ago - and just kept coming. Rose’s synesthesia detracts from the story of eugenics practice in the United States. White men declaring that the knew what was best  - championing Social Darwinism. 
I was surprised to learn that the increased interest in eugenics in the early 20th century in the United States is related to a “better baby” contest at the 1911 Iowa State Fair. “If we can grade livestock and produce on selective breeding traits - why not humans?” 
But back to Rose and her story. I did not connect with Rose as a character - felt like she was always holding back. Although I did love the joke when Mrs. Grissom comments on her dreadful shoes and Rose thinks - “you should see how they sound”.
And what of Helen Calvert? Why did she go to Europe to be a nanny in the first place? We don’t know. When German eugenics experiments in Austria take hold, she gets involved in smuggling children to Switzerland where she is teaching in a convent school. The all-knowing nun in charge of the school sends Helen back to Vienna to find the family she nannied for so she can settle her heart. She finds the father - and lectures him about eugenics - similar to Rose lecturing the doctor and nurses at the Sonoma County home when she left. Both of those passages felt contrived to me.  
The character I really liked was Celine - in Part Two. Disappointed in marriage, in motherhood, in her vineyards - she has become a bitter woman - but she dishes out her vitriol instead of just numbing it with wine. She was nasty - but spoke her mind. 
Overall - the storyline is fine - but too superficial for me.