Take a photo of a barcode or cover
rocknrollbookshelf 's review for:
The Joy Luck Club
by Amy Tan
You know, overall, I really enjoyed reading this book. It was a quick, enjoyable read and I feel like I gained a bit of insight into Chinese culture. That being said, there were enough things that bothered me about this book to add up to this only being a three-star book for me. I read another Goodread member's 3-star review that offered the criticism that the mothers came off as stereotypes at times, and I have to agree. Sometimes I felt like I was watching a Ms. Swan skit from MadTV or looking at a slightly racist Internet meme. This feels a little unfair for me to say since Amy Tan IS Chinese, but I don't know. That aside, the bigger problem for me was the attitudes that all of these family members had toward each other. Maybe the idea of the overly critical mother who almost makes it a point not to understand her daughter hit a little too close to home for me, as I've felt that way often growing up. Mother-daughter relationships are complex and they change and improve over time, as I've learned. My mother and I have experienced many rough times in understanding each other as I've gotten older, but our relationship has improved a lot. Without a clear resolution (to me) in The Joy Luck Club, I just felt uncomfortable, really. I guess with my own challenges with my mother, I need something inspiring, rather than something that leaves me with the sad feeling that maybe my mother really *does* believe all of these terrible things about me, like the mothers in The Joy Luck Club. Am I missing the point because of my own parental paranoia? Maybe, and I'm willing to admit that. Like I said, overall I enjoyed this book a lot. Maybe I'll try another Amy Tan novel, as I liked her style of writing and storytelling. JLC just might not be the one for me.