You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

The Gilly Salt Sisters by Tiffany Baker
3.0

This book starts out really strong. The descriptions of the landscape and the characters are captivating and a little dark. Tiffany Baker is a really good writer and she really proves it by starting out how she did. The story line is really unique and different, with witches and mystical salt, star-crossed lovers and the evil rich family on the hill. Baker builds her characters up, and while some of them are downright unlikable, they're realistic and I didn't want to put the book down.

However, this is a long book, which isn't a problem because there is always something going on, something being revealed, the tide always turning. But the ending comes too quickly, in the span of a couple pages which is meager compared to how much build up there was. I think the book could have ended a without the last chapter. The ending wrapped up too nicely, everything working out too good and frankly, the Gilly sisters didn't deserve what was handed to them. I would have like a less happy ending for them. It didn't fit what what I expected compared to what they have lived through and how tough they are. And some of the decisions they ended up making didn't match what I think they would have agreed to a few pages earlier.

I'm not hating on the length of the book, since it went by so quickly. I only gave this book 3 stars because the ending was so unsatisfying and didn't match the rest of the book I had just got through.