birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Women and Children First by Alina Grabowski
4.5
emotional funny mysterious reflective sad slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character

The only reason that they say “Women and children first” is to test the strength of the lifeboats.
- UNKNOWN (quote at the beginning of the book)

I bought this and then read it right away, and I’m so glad I did. So happy it didn’t sit languishing on my shelf. 

This is a slower, meandering novel with absolutely stunning writing in it. I think I saved more passages here than anything else I’ve read so far this year. Told through multiple POV, each chapter from a different girl or woman in this small seaside town. A teenager dies at a party—and each person is connected to her in some way. I found every perspective so authentic to each character’s voice, almost like a short story in itself, I found myself wishing some would never end. It was clever to see how different people view the same people and situations differently and also the ways in which memory and experience can be so absolutely subjective, and how the truth of existence lies somewhere in the middle, between people, and we can never really touch it.

The mystery is at the crux of the novel, but it’s more about the character studies along the way. A literary fiction mystery, which are some of my favourite things to read. I loved this book, the setting, the writing. I think the only reason it wasn’t a five star read for me was because going from POV to POV takes some situating each time, can feel a bit uncomfortable to me. I think the structure was absolutely intentional to make a point but that doesn’t mean it’s the best reading experience it could have been. I’d have liked to read this book from shifting multiple POVs from just three of the characters I think. I’d have enjoyed spending more time with certain people instead of only getting glimpses of who they are.

But, that’s small potatoes. This book is excellent. Highly recommend to fans of slow going lit fic.