emcrem's profile picture

emcrem 's review for:

He Who Drowned the World by Shelley Parker-Chan
5.0
adventurous emotional inspiring reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Nobody would lift a finger to change the world for us. To make a place for us. What choice did we ever have, but to do it ourselves?

Shelley Parker-Chan’s sequel to her acclaimed novel She Who Became the Sun is a masterpiece.

Parker-Chan once again imbues each of her diverse cast of characters with such vitality and emotion that as readers we are driven to understanding - even condoning - the most appalling acts, and obliged to empathise with the most reviling characters.

The life force that intertwines the fates of these characters is woven even more intricately than in the first novel. The unexpected relationships cultivated in He Who Drowned the World are myriad; each crossing of paths creates moments where the trajectory of the plot threatens to diverge, where we do not know whether to give in to the temptation to endorse the self-made fates of these characters - to root for their destructive paths to satisfaction - or to silently implore them to give in to tenderness, incompleteness, to let go of the pain for the good of their humanity. 

The discord we see in the internal conflict of each character perfectly embodies the struggle of human nature between ambition and compassion, creation and destruction. Each time a character’s true self is further chipped-away at, where humanity is traded for cruelty by “necessity”, we are compelled to question how far the means justify the ends. Like Zhu, we find ourselves asking, was it worth it?

In the final chapters, by directly opposing each successor to power - Ouyang, Baoxiang, and finally Zhu, Parker-Chan gives us her answer. Zhu is only successful in grasping her fate because what she seeks is not an ending, but a beginning. Where the darkness of regret and pain that drives forward Ouyang and Baoxiang only succeeds in their own internal destruction, Zhu breaks this cycle by refusing to conform to it. Instead of sacrificing her true self to get the world, she commands the world to accommodate her, not drowning it in darkness but shining a light upon every shadow in which hides a facet of identity that dares to exist outside of society’s norms.

This ending teaches us that even when all that surrounds us is pain and ruin, we can always choose compassion. There is always hope.