abandonedquests's profile picture

abandonedquests 's review for:

White Smoke by Tiffany D. Jackson
4.0

White Smoke was an odd one for me. It had so much going for it thematically: gentrification, criminalization of drugs, blended family relationships, abuse of power in religion and government, and stigmatization of mental illness. I loved the setup and the concept of a haunted house where the main family is "stuck" because they've accepted an artists residency.

For me, though, there was a bit too much going on. I'm not sure the main mystery made a lot of sense once it was revealed, and it ended so abruptly. I also struggled with how to read Mari: was she "just" a drug addict, did she have a mental illness, and why was her family unwilling to help her? I also wish we'd seen some more buildup with the neighbours before Spoilerthe mob scene, which seemed to happen so quickly.

I listened to the audiobook version of this and the narrator was generally strong (she distinguishes between different voices very well) but the way she handled sound effects was jarring and really took me out of the spooky scenes. I wonder how much that influenced my perception of the flow of the book. Overall I'm pretty torn on this one.