Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Lizards Hold the Sun
by Dani Trujillo
lighthearted
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
N/A
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
I wanted to love this so badly! A romcom featuring indigenous joy and love set on a reserve? Sign me up! But, the execution was just so poorly done it made me sad.
First, this badly needed a pass through an editor—there were line mistakes, hard to follow scene/timeline issues and an ongoing confusion of season. It was the boiling hot of summer, then the too cool spring, then winter seemingly in that order over what seemed like either a couple weeks or over 3 months. I’m not sure if the author has ever been to Canada but our seasons are not that confusing or in that order. It was frustrating and kept taking me out of the story.
The story itself about Xiomara, an archeologist from Mexico who travels to a rural First Nations reserve in northern Canada to excavate a burial site and help open a new museum but falls in love with coworker Calehan Yellowbird—was just, kinda boring? There was no COM in this ROM. It felt like a scattering of educational archeology scenes (I did not sign up for a class, sorry) to just hold place between spicy sex scenes of which there were many—too many some might say (me!). Lots of them outdoors! The bugs! There just wasn’t any sweetness or fun, or anything particularly endearing about these characters and for the late 20 to 30-something aged couple they acted a lot like blushing teenagers which I was not into. With not a lot of character development or inner life.
As for plot, there just wasn’t much of one? Some tension with a hot young chief that gets solved overly conveniently and then the age-old miscommunication trope which I always hate. Have a conversation, you are adults.
The representation was representing though, and I did love to see it… I just wish it was surrounded by a story worthy of it. I’m sad, I wish this was better and I’m kind of surprised by the rave reviews. Representation is important, I agree, but I think our standards can be a little higher for what we’re willing to rave about, too. Hopefully this book does have success and I get more indigenous romcoms that hit me more successfully in the way I want them to. Because for me, this just was not it.
First, this badly needed a pass through an editor—there were line mistakes, hard to follow scene/timeline issues and an ongoing confusion of season. It was the boiling hot of summer, then the too cool spring, then winter seemingly in that order over what seemed like either a couple weeks or over 3 months. I’m not sure if the author has ever been to Canada but our seasons are not that confusing or in that order. It was frustrating and kept taking me out of the story.
The story itself about Xiomara, an archeologist from Mexico who travels to a rural First Nations reserve in northern Canada to excavate a burial site and help open a new museum but falls in love with coworker Calehan Yellowbird—was just, kinda boring? There was no COM in this ROM. It felt like a scattering of educational archeology scenes (I did not sign up for a class, sorry) to just hold place between spicy sex scenes of which there were many—too many some might say (me!). Lots of them outdoors! The bugs! There just wasn’t any sweetness or fun, or anything particularly endearing about these characters and for the late 20 to 30-something aged couple they acted a lot like blushing teenagers which I was not into. With not a lot of character development or inner life.
As for plot, there just wasn’t much of one? Some tension with a hot young chief that gets solved overly conveniently and then the age-old miscommunication trope which I always hate. Have a conversation, you are adults.
The representation was representing though, and I did love to see it… I just wish it was surrounded by a story worthy of it. I’m sad, I wish this was better and I’m kind of surprised by the rave reviews. Representation is important, I agree, but I think our standards can be a little higher for what we’re willing to rave about, too. Hopefully this book does have success and I get more indigenous romcoms that hit me more successfully in the way I want them to. Because for me, this just was not it.