After Nancy Drew, this is my second attempt at reading YA. I can't say I loved it, but I did enjoy reading it. I knew it wouldn't be the same as reading the original.
The narration was good, though Jamie was a confused boy. I don't like reading about kids taking drugs, so I wasn't that impressed with Charlotte's addiction. No doubt it was put in to show the resemblance to Sherlock, but well...
Yet, I liked her grit. She was not as cold as she projected herself to be. And having a heroine who is not perfect was a good change. She had a wide range of emotions and she managed them well.
Her relationship with Milo was cute to read.