Take a photo of a barcode or cover
librarianlayla 's review for:
Rosemary and the Witches of Pendle Hill
by Samantha Giles
I received an eARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This had all the makings to be a magical adventure, perfect for middle grade readers, however I felt that it was missing something. There were moments when the flow of the story was a little jagged and at times terminology ect seemed to exceed what I would expect a 9 year old girl, in modern times, to use.
That all being said, I did appreciate that Adi was presented as being on the autism spectrum and that there were themes of depression, grief and recovery throughout. The characters were diverse, sometimes wacky but mostly wonderful. I do think that the idea behind the story was lovely and had great potential, however, the writing style just didn't click with me.
This had all the makings to be a magical adventure, perfect for middle grade readers, however I felt that it was missing something. There were moments when the flow of the story was a little jagged and at times terminology ect seemed to exceed what I would expect a 9 year old girl, in modern times, to use.
That all being said, I did appreciate that Adi was presented as being on the autism spectrum and that there were themes of depression, grief and recovery throughout. The characters were diverse, sometimes wacky but mostly wonderful. I do think that the idea behind the story was lovely and had great potential, however, the writing style just didn't click with me.