Take a photo of a barcode or cover
illustrated_librarian 's review for:
Bewilderment
by Richard Powers
reflective
sad
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Theo Byrne is an astrobiologist researching the possibility of life on exoplanets lightyears away. He's also a widowed father to Robin, a nine-year-old with a deep empathy for nature whose behaviour can be challenging. After a violent outburst in school, Robin and Theo's bond will be tested to its limits as Theo must choose how best to help his son in a world that's breaking.
Let me start by saying I fully expected to love this. Off the back of reading Orbital I was so in the mood for more space, more wonder, and am fully behind the melding of this with cli-fi, activism, and criticisms of human destruction of the planet. And there were tender father-son moments marvelling at our universe, but also an unchallenged anti-medicine streak that ruined things for me.
Robin is neurodivergent-coded, though a diagnosis is never committed to, and struggles because of it. Theo is desperate to keep him off medication given his young age. And listen, I get it. I'm no advocate for making the output of Big Pharma seem uncritically good and cuddly, but medication can save lives and give people the space to heal. Add to this Theo putting Robin through an experimental and unproven therapy instead, and I started to lose it with this story. At one point Theo says 'no doctor can diagnose my son better than I can' and possibly my eyes haven't stopped rolling since.
Also, haven't we moved on from referring to neurodivergent people as 'rare' and 'special'? Particularly gross to me was the use of 'otherworldly', as if Robin is a visiting alien who doesn't really belong, here only to teach "ordinary" humans a valuable lesson. This icky feeling was only intensified by the odd stylistic choice to have Robin's dialogue in italics the whole way through, like he's a little ghost not fully in his own life.
I did feel huge empathy for Robin discovering his own smallness, the terrible weight of his care for living things and his inability to help them, but he also felt like a mouthpiece for Powers to get some quasi-deep quotes in.
Overall this felt clumsy and shallow, and nowhere near as profound as it thought it was.