orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

This Is How You Lose the Time War by Max Gladstone, Amal El-Mohtar
2.5
adventurous challenging mysterious reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus: N/A

Tldr/Summary:
The set pieces in which the characters operate and the honestly nonsensical ways they deliver letters to each other were really, really enjoyable.
However I barely cared for the relationship between the two characters, them as individuals or their character/plot progression. 

Long Version:
The chapters are always split into two parts: a description of where the current PoV character (either Red or Blue) is and how they receive a letter from the other one and then the contents of said letter. These letters usually serve to further the character development of the characters and their relationship to each other.

I really enjoyed the set piece descriptions. Though the creativity of them varies (for example a sinking Atlantis or a prehistoric religious pilgrim trail deep underground) the descriptions of them were always vivid and basically never boring.

The ways the characters encode and decode their letters to each other were also very fun. They almost always make no sense (for example in the first chapter Red receives an ordinary paper letter and has to burn it, because its contents are hidden inside the shapes of the flames that form upon burning the paper) but the way their acts, discoveries and reactions are described kept me engaged nonetheless.

Then however we move to their interpersonal relationship. After a certain point I kinda stopped caring about this half of the novel. It is effectively a Romeo and Juliette style set up (two soldiers from rivaling armies who would both die if their interactions with each other were ever spotted) with one more emotional and impulsive character and one that's more calm and rational.
I just don't really feel like their relationship progressed naturally. To me it was more like "Oh, we've spent a while being like this to each other, time to go to the next stage of our relationship."

The two also have a few philosophical discussions about various topics. For example Red stems from a highly technologized society of lab grown cyborgs while Blue was grown in a garden of a civilization that has very close ties to nature and plants. How their origins shape their world views and if one of the two war parties is ultimately more right than the other is one topic of discussion. 
I was kind of whatever on those. They're not actively bad but also not never before seen brilliance. You might enjoy them but you probably won't draw any eye opening life lessons from them.

Now I will admit that it's been a few months since I read the story and I started disengaging towards the end. But I didn't really understand the character motivations and the end goal of their plans. Therefore the resolution of the plot kind of confused me. But I can't really judge if that's a me problem or if the writers are to blame.