Take a photo of a barcode or cover
lispectorsexual 's review for:
The Chandelier
by Clarice Lispector
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
tense
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
On Her Writing:
As always, Clarice utilises an external realm — mystified sentences mused with poetry, unusual punctuations, a repetition or emphasis of certain words, and a common trait of not wanting to have long sentences — and this is where she bewitches you, as Benjamin Moser would say, and loses you in her beautiful nonsense. If we were to look at her internal world, that would be where meaning lies behind this unusual writing style, poetry, and punctuations, and certain philosophies can then be obtained. And that is because none of it is never for the sake of appearance or aesthetics, whether she is conscious of it or not.
With our main character, Virgínia, we are then immersed in her world from a third person narrative which I think is a righteous choice for a character such as her. Because like her, we are spectators of her flowing life. The story is an exploration of memory (Virgínia’s) through fragmented episodes or consciousness, and so we never spend too much time centred around one scene. Clarice could portray three different scenes, of different times and in no order of their occurrence, all on the same page, hinting at the untameable act of remembrance, one thought giving birth to the other, and sometimes without connection.
A Short Analysis:
“She’d been flowing life” And that is our opening line, so sudden, so abrupt, so spontaneous and without warning. And yet it has everything we need to know about our Virgínia. When she inspects the essence of her being, she becomes nauseated and she tries not to intellectualise over her own existence — “She was thinking without intelligence about her own reality as if discerning and could never use what she was feeling, her meditation was a way of living.”
We must think of her as a leaf fallen from a tree (her mother) and onto a river (life), and so chooses to not question where the water’s flowing but rather to just flow with it in silence, and it is from that silence that she begins to live. To live without question — “Slowly, from the silence, her being was starting to live more, an abandoned instrument that started making sound all by itself…” And so for Virgínia, her life was that of becoming rather than that of being. A somewhat continuous metamorphosis. It is through this that we again look at the majority of Clarice’s characters and how they come to terms with their existence or existence in general. They are never pessimists or nihilists, to them existence is beautiful and tiresome, and so they wish to die or having to never been born. Suicidal ideations are a foreign concept to them.
A thing that she loved to do was to think about the future, and although it was a paradoxical thinking because she loved the thought of somewhere other than now, she was anxious because anything could happen and it would be out of her control, but she was connecting herself and the next day through desire.
Things outside of her own self never worried her that much, thus she was never concerned about the existence of God or prayer, although even if she was to stand before the idea of God it was not something she would be fearful of (P.65-66).
She would proceed to be calm and innocent. She only ever bothered herself with such intellectualism because of her admiration for Daniel. Having placed distance between the two of them, she desperately sought to bridge the gap between them and to be accepted by Daniel, at least have it be him since the entirety of her family left her isolated. Her father being verbally and physically abusive, her mother only caring about Esmeralda because she reminds her of her youth, and Esmeralda herself not wanting much to do with her younger siblings.
The second half of the book is centred around Virgínia being a bit more older, her thinking is broadened and so our interpretations begin to expand as we no longer take things solely from the narrator, but Virgínia too. She questions her femininity — her existential crises is tied with first trying to understand what does it actually mean to be a woman. (There’s also recurring theme that plays inside Virgínia’s head regarding the need to be “pure” again, and that it was within her virginity that she felt she was most powerful). Has she always been a woman, or is it an act of becoming? An ontological question is what we would call it when getting metaphysical. Each question that she poses outwards only manages to terrifyingly bring her back to herself. Deconstructing the structure of her own thoughts and the objects within her apartment, understanding their existence and that their very existence is independent from her, and that being able to perceive them is proof enough of their existence: “the thought of the thing exists as much as the thing itself, not in words of explanation but as another order of facts; quick facts, subtle, visible exactly through some sense, as only the sense of smell perceives the flower's perfume”.
This excerpt kind of reminded me of Hegel’s Otherization especially when she extended it towards living creatures like animals, but let us not expand on that and remain within the events of this book.
I ended up taking too long because I feared rushing it and ending up clueless, and with Clarice it’s better to take it as slow as possible and grasping every part of it.
And so here I conclude my review in order to not make it too long fearing that I might give away too much of Virgínia’s secret and what the meaning of O Lustre is.
Some of my favourite quotes:
What had existed in her life was an indistinct and infinite power, really infinite and pallid. But she could never have demonstrated the existence of that power as it would be difficult to prove that she felt like going on, that the color of the rose was pleasing to her, that she was feeling strength, that she was connected to the stone in the garden.
Because if I am free, if with a gesture I can make everything new again.
She’d need a secret life in order to be able to exist.
Now it was becoming clear: it was true! everything was existing so freely that she could even overturn the order of her feelings, not be afraid of death, fear life, desire hunger, hate happy things, laugh at tranquility . . .
Would seeing the truth be different from inventing the truth?