I stopped reading this book at about 80 pages. The shadow magic is too abstract and I couldn’t understand it or get into it. It seems Charlie creates her own drama and has low self esteem. Even though there is a murder by the time I quit, I didn’t feel interested enough to continue. That said, if you like this type of magical element, it is described very well. Lots of detail (and I still didn’t get it). Book is written well and author has a talent for intricate storytelling.