I may have a hard time rating this series because i listened to the unabridged version so I am going to write the main overall review here. I’ll rate the books individually by star rating tho. I think that I would’ve loved this book more if I was younger but it had the right amount of whimsy and mystery to keep me reading. I will say I like how fast the author aged the characters, I feel like it’s rare to see characters start as a child and age up to an adult in a series this short. Rose annoyed me a bit at first but she started to grow on me and the same can be said for Neeve. It took awhile until I started liking them to be honest. This series is very easy to get through and there’s a satisfying end!