maxarcreads's profile picture

maxarcreads 's review for:

The Book Swap by Tessa Bickers
3.25

This is a 3.25 for me. For me I don't think this book is really being marketed properly as based on the description and cover. I thought this was going to be a romantic comedy with a bookish twist on a you got mail situation. For me reading this book it was not a romantic comedy and while there were romantic elements it felt more like that was a subplot. For me this book was a little heavier on subject matter as there was more focus on serious elements like the passing of a friend, grief, depression, cheating and rough family dynamics. This book was more focused on self-healing and growth as well as healing through a mutual love of books. None of that is a bad thing but when I am expecting one thing and get to reading it and it is something else then it does turn into a bit of a disappointment me to me. It was still an interesting book with an interesting concept I just don't think it is being marketed correctly. It is also being tagged as a 2nd chance romance but technically while there were feelings for one another they were never together and that to me is more of the one that got away than a 2nd chance romance. 

As I said the romance kind of seemed like a bit of a subplot because while they did exchange books and write notes to one another the notes themselves were just standard getting to know one another and I personally didn't see anything in the notes that would stir feelings of love. I mean you can certainly bond over notes but these questions just at times felt like a bookish get to know you session which is a great starting point but to immediately jump to love just seems like a bit of a leap. Especially once they figured out who each other were and all their past history good and bad that once they apologized are immediately saying their in love with one another seems a bit much. I mean it's a book and once they apologize and set their differences aside it would totally make sense to start to rebuild the relationship and grow towards love but the leap without the work especially since this book seems to have a lot about working on yourself and growing seemed too easy. 

As to the writing I do think this book starts off a little rough and was a little boring, but it does smooth itself out as it went on in terms of writing. 

As to the characters themselves while I can appreciate and understand all the important elements the author is trying to portray it did at times make at least Erin a little unlikable. While I totally sympathize with her situation just like her sister tells her she is a little judgmental and willing to write someone or something off for one issue. Like she quit a sale job while she was unemployed because the manager was a little "weird" for wanting to mock play a customer interaction and dressed up. Is it unusual yes but Erin never had retail experience so who cares if the manager wanted to put on a hat to help teach her how to interact with customers. Like girl your unemployed and got bills just do the job while you look for something else. James wasn't always my favorite because he tried to push people into what he thought was success even when it's not something they wanted for themselves. But when you learn why him and Erin had the falling out and what he was going through at school and at home your heart does break for him a little. Doesn't make what he did right towards Erin but as you read what was happening in the scene it's understandable. 

So, I do think this book had an interesting idea and concept and while the writing was a little rough at the start it did smooth out and there were moments in the book that my heart strings were tugged on. But I do think the marketing and cover do not accurately portray what this book is about and may disappoint some readers like me expecting one thing and getting another. 

this book is about Erin who is still trying to cope with the loss of her best friend but knows she needs to move on but doesn't quite know how to do that. After a rough day at work where in the end she quits she decides the best thing to do is to get rid of all the clutter in her life starting with her room. But in her what brings me joy mindset cleanse she accidently donates to a small little library her annotated copy of To Kill a Mockingbird. She checks back frequently in hopes it will turn back up when it does, and it turns out the reader left his own comments and notes in the margins along with a note of another book notated for her to read Great Expectations. This starts a pen pal exchange through two lovers of books as they read through some classics and start asking questions and getting to know one another. As her feelings start to grow for her mystery man, she starts to wonder who he might be and if this friendship they are building could potentially become more. Little does she know that her mystery man is someone she knows that she has a rough past with. So, when identities become known will they be able to look past the cover and see the person they have been getting to know through the pages of their very loved books. 

I received an ARC copy from netgally and HTP in exchange for an honest review.