Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kaylaramoutar 's review for:
What If It's Us
by Becky Albertalli, Adam Silvera
Somewhere between a 3.5 and a 4.
I liked this a lot, but had some problems with it. My biggest issue is that I found it hard to discern whose section I was in; I personally thought their voices could be more distinct. It's good to know that if Albertalli and Silvera write another book together instead with one main character, there would be no problem staying within the same voice. My other issue is that I felt that Ben and Arthur were completely different ages; Arthur felt so much younger. This was shown especially when he reacted to everyone in his life in the climax of the novel; Ben, his parents, his friends. I did not enjoy how he refused to hear anyone's side but then complained how Ben only texted him once. ("Ben, who texted me once. Literally once. And there you have it. That's how hard he was willing to fight for me.") I just couldn't deal with that.
Besides that - I enjoyed the novel a lot. Ben was a very interesting character and I'd like to read more of him. The side characters - both of their friends and their parents - were well written and mostly fleshed out.
These two writers are good together, so I hope they write another.
I liked this a lot, but had some problems with it. My biggest issue is that I found it hard to discern whose section I was in; I personally thought their voices could be more distinct. It's good to know that if Albertalli and Silvera write another book together instead with one main character, there would be no problem staying within the same voice. My other issue is that I felt that Ben and Arthur were completely different ages; Arthur felt so much younger. This was shown especially when he reacted to everyone in his life in the climax of the novel; Ben, his parents, his friends. I did not enjoy how he refused to hear anyone's side but then complained how Ben only texted him once. ("Ben, who texted me once. Literally once. And there you have it. That's how hard he was willing to fight for me.") I just couldn't deal with that.
Besides that - I enjoyed the novel a lot. Ben was a very interesting character and I'd like to read more of him. The side characters - both of their friends and their parents - were well written and mostly fleshed out.
These two writers are good together, so I hope they write another.