chrisssl 's review for:

Birnam Wood by Eleanor Catton
3.5
dark tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

In the first of the novel's three acts, one would be forgiven for wondering where the "thriller" aspect factors in.  The author takes her time introducing each of her principle characters with a surprisingly front-loaded amount of background and psyche.  The rich interiority of these characters is far and away the best part of the book.   The author leisurely scrutinizes the motives, insecurities and unconscious behaviours of her characters with  almost Austen-like, detail.  Each of our three principle characters (Mira, Shelley and Tony) are young white middle-class college-educated progressive ideologues part of an activist farming collective called Birnam Wood.  If you're wondering how much mileage you can get out of this shared background before it becomes repetitive and insufferable, the answer is: quite a lot.  Catton shows her skill here, crafting diverse, memorable histories, allowing each  character to be distinct and play off one another in unexpected and enjoyable ways.  These characters are fully-formed, believable, realistic and admirable in their own way, but the author never allows them or their musings to grow too grandiose or self-regarding before cutting them down to size: kindly but firmly pointing out their bullshit and allowing their righteousness to be mixed with pettiness, naiveté and delightful contradiction.  It's a fine balancing of taking the piss without fully denying the characters' sincerity.

The setting is bravely 21st century.  It doesn't shy away from internet-searches, pervasive cell-phones and geolocation, mass e-mail chains and emojis, but neither is it particularly inspired in dealing with any of them.   A minor exception is that a frequent source of humour in the book is contrasting the deep, sometimes self-aware introspection of Catton's characters with the infantile, contrary ways they express themselves in text-messages.

Once a lengthy but splendid period of character introduction is complete, the plot begins to take shape through the mysterious billionaire Robert Lemoine and the forested land he's so interested in (no, it's not called Dunsinane), isolated by New Zealand's South Island mountains and national parks.  What is different here is that Catton chooses to play all her cards up front: elucidating the billionaire's plot and character with no less clarity than she affords her protagonists' own backstories.  Thus the intrigue driving the book is less about progressively revealing hidden character motives or actions and more about observing richly written characters bounce off each other from a privileged position of omniscience.  This doesn't make it sound like a high-stakes page-turner but such is the nature of Catton's characters and writing that the book remains suspenseful and compelling and I quickly finished the back-half of this book in a single frenzied sitting.

But there is a weakness with how the author deals with the pivotal billionaire character.  While it kickstarts the traditional thriller aspects of the story, it also exposes (almost certainly intentionally by the author) the sheer cartoonish evilness of the billionaire: limitless resources, a technocratic surveillance apparatus, and a goofier Tom Clancy-ish characterization than one would expect from a Booker-prize winning author.  It does feel like the author knows what she's doing here - contrasting the deeply lived and nuanced experiences Birnam Wood with the insipid, empty, uninspired avarice of a man of obscene means.  It's a pathetically banal portrait of the parasitic ultra-rich but it doesn't quite manage to correct the cliches that infects a taut character drama with covert paramilitaries,  tech-bro contrivances, and nameless henchmen in black SUVs.

At this point the book feels far less like Macbeth than it does Othello, but without the tension that comes with Iago contriving from an inferior position.  Any substantive parallel with Shakespeare's Scottish Play has eluded me, as has the ecological aspect of this eco-thriller.  Beyond the surface of its setting, there is an unfortunate lack of attention and craft spent on writing about the protected environment which Birnam Wood seeks to nurture and maintain (and which other interests seek to exploit).  The author seems more interested (or equipped) in incisively focusing on her characters while neglecting the very land they seem so bent on fighting for.  One wonders if this is meant to reflect to a possible shallowness of Birnam Wood's own regard for the environment (while being naturally drawn to interpersonal dramas and gossip).  Landscapes are described without much aesthetic creativity or lyricism and the author's only literary device here seems to be the number of synonyms she can find for colours.

On the general quality of the prose, this is my first novel of her's, so I can't tell if she's employing a specific choice here or if it's her general style, but Catton writes in a fairly direct and non-lyrical manner.  The novel enjoys conjunctions...a lot.  In fact at times the book seems intent on stringing sentences together using every possible conjunction in the English language.  This can lead to laborious sentences that work brilliantly during moments of deep internal anger and breathless momentum of thought from the characters.  This might otherwise be construed as a bit ostentatious, if not for how the author always gives a wink at the reader, knowing to some extent these extreme run-ons are a bit full of shit.  It works less well and becomes more obvious and jarring towards the end of the novel when it is employed more widely for working through mundane actions required of the plot.  Like a lot of contemporary novels, this leads to a rote listing things and is a bit annoying and perfunctory to get through.

Overall this book is both less thriller, less ecological, and even less contemporary than its premise and marketing might suggest.  To me, it seems to be about nothing so much as the versatility of greed in subverting and corrupting whatever adversity it comes across.  We see characters identify danger without any difficulty, but always convince themselves they can escape the scorpion's sting.  And what few characters manage to resist the spell and seduction of these institutions of greed and power, do so only by a lack of exposure or utter serendipity.

The novel is more of a tragedy hiding in a modern-day character-rich thriller.  It's not perfect.  The prose is uneven,  the natural world feels neglected and underwritten, and parts of the story can become clumsy camp.   But this novel is surprisingly bold in its choices, for better or worse, and any enjoyment one gets from it will be sustained on the strength of its wonderfully realized characters (who are each in their own way, up their own asses) and unflinchingly dark destination (its abruptness only heightens its sharpness).