whatsallyreadnext's profile picture

whatsallyreadnext 's review for:

Falling by T.J. Newman
3.0
adventurous tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I really wanted to like Falling by flight attendant-turned-author T.J. Newman and had such high hopes from what I'd heard from bookstagram plus the blurb was attention-grabbing for sure. Unfortunately I was left a bit frustrated and disappointed by this book and the direction it took and here's why.

The concept of the book made it sound like it'd be a promising read - an experienced pilot boards a flight to New York, 143 passengers are on-board, he then discovers that his family have been kidnapped and for them to be safe, he has to crash the plane. I particularly enjoyed the quick pace, the characters of the flight crew and the bond they formed.
However I was really disappointed to discover fairly early on in the book that the terrorists were Syrian Kurds and their motive for killing innocent people is so that people would start paying attention to the horrific deaths happening in the Middle East. For Newman to write Middle Easterns into the role of the terrorists is incredibly problematic and just fuels more hatred and negativity towards them. She did write a bit of a back story for the terrorists so that the reader could develop some empathy for them but I felt like the damage had already been done.

I also found the opening chapter to be unnecessarily gruesome and not in keeping with the rest of the book which was pretty tame in comparison. There were some parts of the story which I found a bit unrealistic - namely one of the characters somehow surviving consecutive life-threatening scenarios. It seemed like the author was writing this with a movie adaptation in mind so I wasn't surprised that there has been a $1.5M film rights deal agreed.

In summary, I really wanted to love it but it ended up being a problematic read for me.