alixmcinally's profile picture

alixmcinally 's review for:

Fate & Furies by Helen Scheuerer
3.5
adventurous mysterious fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

i have such mixed feelings about this book! overall, it was solid and i definitely enjoyed it. however, i do have a few criticisms that i do think impacted my enjoyment.

first off, the things i enjoyed! i really loved seeing new characters get introduced, and anya in particular was soooo interesting! i loved learning more about her backstory and what her life was like as a child. that being said, i do wish that we had gotten a few more scenes of her and thea connecting, because it seemed like they were cool with each other pretty fast despite everything that had happened. hopefully we get some more scenes of them in the next book cause i think that would add a great element of emotional depth to the book that i felt was lacking at times.

once again, the side characters were great! that’s something that i feel this author does very well, and the continued comic relief of cal and kipp was so fun.

i did really enjoy the plot of this book, despite it feeling a bit like filler (which i don’t always necessarily think is a bad thing, as long as it is still keeping you entertained and interested). i especially loved seeing thea take part in the great rite, i thought there were some really intense and emotional scenes during that and it was really nice seeing her finally achieve her dream!

however, i do have some criticisms. first off, i feel like thea forgave wilder very very fast, and it seemed like it didn’t take much convincing at all to change her mind about everything she thought she had ever known. i wish that that had been done a bit more slowly and that she eventually started to change her mind and realise the truth. i think this would’ve added a lot more emotion and depth to the plot of this book if she had slowly come to terms with everything she believed being false! it felt quite rushed despite this book being almost 500 pages.

secondly, despite loving the  introduction of the new characters, i wish we actually got to know more about them! there was one or two scenes with anya, but we don’t really know anything else about the group, how they met, what their individual backstories are etc. i feel like that would’ve really improved the book for me as i’m a big side character person! some added lore would’ve made the book even more interesting for me.

finally, i would say the weakest part of this book (and the series as a whole) would have to be the magic system. it feels like theas magic is completely forgotten about most of the time, and she barely even uses it, yet in this book she’s devastated over the fact she no longer has access to it. this was super confusing to me and i feel like her and wren’s magic is the most underdeveloped part of the series. we only got one scene of them training their magic, but yet in this book thea says multiple times that she feels like a part of her is gone. this was super super annoying to read about, and i wish we actually learnt more about her magic and she actually had time to train and use it! i think that’s my biggest criticism of this series, and i think it would actually benefit if that whole
plot point was erased.

overall, pretty solid middle of a series book despite its flaws, and i am curious to see how it’s all going to be tied up in the last one!