You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
illustrated_librarian 's review for:
Ask Me Again
by Clare Sestanovich
challenging
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Eva meets Jamie by chance and despite having little in common — where she's observant and cautious, he's easy and eccentric — they instantly forge a deep friendship. As Eva goes off to college and falls in and out of love, Jamie is drawn to radical experiments in politics and religion. Though their separate spheres draw them apart, they both circle the same question: how can you define yourself and your beliefs in a divided world?
This is one where I'd tentatively suggest ignoring the blurb. Eva and Jamie's friendship is at times full of heart but mostly happens off the page; Jamie's influence on Eva's life is largely created by the shape of his absence, a pillar she allies with or defines herself against as she grows up. The blurb also makes more of their class differences (Eva is middle-class, Jamie from a vague super-rich background) than the actual text does. Again, the influence of this is definitely there but subtle, and if you go in expecting a focus on class critique you'll be disappointed.
With that aside, this is a sharply observed literary coming of age that ultimately grapples with how we make meaning in a difficult world — be it through our politics, relationships, religion, advice columns — and how those things in isolation fall short.
Sestanovich is clearly a gifted writer and the prose here is searching yet precise, cool and clear in a way that's easy to gulp down. The scope of around a decade or so is deftly managed, full of tiny revelations and disenchantments that constitute growing up, alongside the texture of an ordinary life.
I do wish it had got into the meat of the philosophical questions around what we owe each other and the world more, especially through Jamie's character who starts off promising but fades into the background. There's a distance and loneliness to the book where I wanted a beating heart — Eva quietly asks for more from life, more connection, more meaning, but I'm not sure she found it. Maybe she settles, but maybe we all do. And maybe that's okay.
Thanks to Picador for my ARC.
Thanks to Picador for my ARC.