Take a photo of a barcode or cover
illustrated_librarian 's review for:
Why Women Grow: Stories of Soil, Sisterhood and Survival
by Alice Vincent
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
I got unfairly grumpy with this the first time I read it. From the blurb, I was expecting a book of interviews or essays and instead found the author much more present in the text than I anticipated. The first time around this felt a little overbearing; I wanted more space for the women Vincent spoke to about their gardens and less about her. On a second read, reframing it in my mind as memoir mixed with garden writing, it worked much better for me.
Vincent is at a transitional point in life: she's settled with the partner/house/job combo we're all told is the ultimate sign of success. She feels very lucky and yet, she's conscious that she's performing a certain type of straight femininity that's beginning to feel like a trap. Questions about children are coming now she's married, her friendships are changing, her independence different-feeling than before.
In speaking to a huge number of women, often very different from herself, about why they turn to the soil, I saw how Vincent learned from everyone she spoke to and folded their experiences into her own.
They were generous, honest conversations that opened up ever more paths for how womanhood can look, not fewer.
I liked that in her questioning she resisted drawing a straight line between women and nurturing as some sort of universal quality, especially when it comes to children. Lots of the women she spoke to weren't natural gardeners, but had persevered anyway. Some gardened to claim space for themselves from family life, some to commemorate the loss of a dearly wanted child, some precisely because they had no children and so had time for a hobby.
One of the women Vincent spoke to described her lack of wanting children as almost a physical space in herself — a place she reaches into to check if the desire is there, and finds nothing. A lightbulb flicked on for me: 'aha! There it is, that's exactly how I feel.' Therein lies the value of Vincent's project, of turning to others when your own path feels uncertain. The reasons women garden are as myriad as women themselves, and the soft, feminine language she writes in makes this a gently meditative read.
Vincent is at a transitional point in life: she's settled with the partner/house/job combo we're all told is the ultimate sign of success. She feels very lucky and yet, she's conscious that she's performing a certain type of straight femininity that's beginning to feel like a trap. Questions about children are coming now she's married, her friendships are changing, her independence different-feeling than before.
In speaking to a huge number of women, often very different from herself, about why they turn to the soil, I saw how Vincent learned from everyone she spoke to and folded their experiences into her own.
They were generous, honest conversations that opened up ever more paths for how womanhood can look, not fewer.
I liked that in her questioning she resisted drawing a straight line between women and nurturing as some sort of universal quality, especially when it comes to children. Lots of the women she spoke to weren't natural gardeners, but had persevered anyway. Some gardened to claim space for themselves from family life, some to commemorate the loss of a dearly wanted child, some precisely because they had no children and so had time for a hobby.
One of the women Vincent spoke to described her lack of wanting children as almost a physical space in herself — a place she reaches into to check if the desire is there, and finds nothing. A lightbulb flicked on for me: 'aha! There it is, that's exactly how I feel.' Therein lies the value of Vincent's project, of turning to others when your own path feels uncertain. The reasons women garden are as myriad as women themselves, and the soft, feminine language she writes in makes this a gently meditative read.