lindseysliterarythings's profile picture

lindseysliterarythings 's review for:

Katabasis by R.F. Kuang
3.0

Alice is going to Hell. No, really.

Alice Law and fellow academic Peter Murdoch (swoon) have to travel through all layers of Hell to find their professor and rescue him. 

Storywise, I was in it. I think this sounds fascinating. Yesss, give us allll the academic and religious critiques! I wanna hear it. Unfortunately, that's about where it begins and ends with its quality.

Alice Law is so shallowly written I was actively rooting for her downfall. The setting was hastily put together with awkward academic references that were the same references critiqued for being elitist throughout the actual story. The pacing was incredibly disjointed, leaving certain scenes moving so fast I blinked and they were over, and others so slow I was begging for it to end. The last 30% had so much build up, only for resolution to be achieved within literal paragraphs.

The main characters had no chemistry, not even platonic, let alone romantic or sexual. The development was nonexistent, and due to their lack of personalities I had a hard time being invested in their success. Additionally, they were never challenged. Literally every miniscule challenge they came across, the characters would say "we aren't doing this" and then... just didn't? They arguably had too much of an easy time in Hell. 

With nothing new or interesting to add to the conversation on academia and elitism - I've debated where to rate this star-wise. I'm giving it a solid 3. I think I enjoyed it more than I didn't, and while bored for a solid chunk of it, I still needed to know what was destined for my sweet boyfriend, Peter Murdoch. Kuang can, and has, done better. 

Thanks Harper Voyager and Netgalley for the e-ARC! KATABASIS - out August 26!