I found this much more enjoyable than the first in the series, and that is primarily to do with Lirael herself. And the library that she works in... who doesn't love a library full of books and creepy things? To be honest, I find the Clayr as a whole more compelling than the Abhorsen or royal lines, and though it was clear to me very early on what Lirael's role would come to be, I still enjoyed seeing her get there.

I did not enjoy Sam. Every time the book switched perspectives to this spoilt, whiny little brat the story became instantly less enjoyable. I am no longer surprised at his sister's attitude towards him - he's damn lucky Ellimere never pushed him off a building! Better for everyone if she did. The point where I lost all hope for him was when, knowing his friend was in danger, he decided to take the longer, more dangerous route (instead of the quick safe river voyage) to get to said friend, simply because the long way had an inn with jellied eels that he wanted to try. Go die in a fire, Sameth. No-one will miss you, and your very presence is dragging down an awesome character.

He single-handedly nearly dropped this review from four stars to three, but what saves it (barely) is the text doesn't fall over itself making excuses for him.