Ahoy there mateys! This was a 2023 Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Best Fantasy.  This is not me normal style of fantasy books but the crew was talking about it so I gave it a shot.  This ended up being just okay.  I really enjoyed the female relationships in this and the form of magic that the witches have.  That said, it seemed like the women barely survived the evil man out to kill them all.  I did not really enjoy the ending.  I did very much enjoy the beginning of this book and the set-up.  I found Lucky to be a lovely main character and also enjoyed her grandmother, Stella.  Not sad I read it but the details are not sticking very clearly in me noggin. Arrrr!