You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
creepshowcassie 's review for:
One for My Enemy
by Olivie Blake
adventurous
emotional
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
This book felt... incredibly frustrating. This is my first book by Olivie Blake and, while I did enjoy her writing style, this book was just not for me. Retellings are always hit and miss for me, personally, and with seemingly two retellings smashed together the narrative felt incredibly disjointed and all over the place. Maybe it was my fault for not realizing this book was a retelling, but I was initially pulled in by the urban fantasy setting and witchy elements. Both things, however, could not combat the frustrations I felt toward this book.
The insta-love between Sasha and Lev constantly had me rolling my eyes. The constant hot-and-cold attitudes from both gave me whiplash, and the constant monologues kept making me cringe. Similarly, the romance between Dima and Masha felt empty. We're supposed to believe these two were star-crossed lovers, but we never got to see any of the buildup when they were growing up. All that conflict was told, rather than shown, and I'm just supposed to be invested in their love story? Yawn.
Also, the confrontations near the end of the book felt incredibly anticlimactic. Maybe it's because I like my protagonists a little more unhinged, but with both women out for vengeance, I was left wanting more. Yes, I understand vengeance cannot heal grief, but when these characters spend a majority of this book seeking out said revenge, it leaves something to be desired when it fizzles out like it did.
Lastly, the magic system and this society of witches was not fleshed out in the slightest. There are constant references to Old World rules, the Borough Witches being this authoritative power, and witches magic being stored in their body, but what else? It was never explained or expanded upon in a way that made me understand how the magic works and why this magical government body was put in place.
Ultimately, this felt like a slog to get through. I thought about DNFing it, but I had done that with a book I was reading prior, so I wanted to try and stick this one out. I did enjoy Blake's writing style; it was very beautiful! But the story itself left a lot to be desired, and I just powered through this to get to my other library holds.