While this book may not be wholly original, it is definitely charming. Of course, there are definitely plot threads, character types and twists I've seen many times before, but, then again, I'm not the intended audience. A kid starting to figure out which genre they like will definitely get a kick out of this book, especially if they're fans of A Series of Unfortunate Events. It reminded me a lot of that series if the Baudelaires had actually had one ounce of luck in their lives.

For those afraid of hearing nothing but Neil's voice throughout the book, it does tend to happen. I can hear his enthusiasm and love for magic through the tone, but I wouldn't call it distracting.

I wouldn't say it's an easy book for adults to enjoy, as it is fairly simple and uses certain plot threads that have been done better in other stories, but it's harmless fun for those interested.