This was a book full of heart and while it does have a HEA, there is a good deal of trauma in the story, so please check the trigger warnings so you can be informed.  

Elijah is cast out of his traditional Amish family for being gay.  He becomes homeless and narrowly avoids freezing to death when he is rescued by a queer couple who run an animal sanctuary farm.  On the farm he meets the farm hand, Jon, who is himself running away from a traumatic loss.

This is a not-quite enemies to lovers story as initially Jon is very cold and unwelcoming to Elijah, but the two grow together into a caring romantic pair.  This is a small-town second-chance-romance story with mutual pining, lots of baked goods, loving animals, and personal character growth.