Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review! Review soon to come!

‘When I Was You’ follows Kelly Medina, who one day receives a call from her pediatrician’s office to confirm her ‘well-baby’ appointment. Kelly becomes curious about this other Kelly with her name and who uses her pediatrician too. She then wants to learn more about this other Kelly.

‘When I Was You’ is a well-written page-turning thriller. The story is very atmospheric and completely immerses the reader. The story centers around Kelly when she meets the other Kelly Medina and becomes obsessed with her son, Sullivan. Kelly decides to help Sullivan and his young mother. This book is written in the second person which began the tension on page one and carried out until the last page. This is a gripping thriller that has an insane plot twist that I didn’t see coming. I highly recommend readers checking this book out. And I will keep my eye out for Garza’s books in the future.