Take a photo of a barcode or cover
abandonedquests 's review for:
All I Want for Christmas
by Maggie Knox
Last year, I enjoyed Maggie Knox’s Christmas romcom, The Holiday Swap, and I was excited to read their new book. Plus, All I Want for Christmas is an enemies-to-lovers story set around a country music competition show, which sounded *so* fun.
Unfortunately, it didn’t work for me at all. There wasn’t any spark or good banter between Max and Sadie, the main couple. They fought and broke up over and over and over, and always over some misunderstanding or leaping to the worst conclusions.
In romcoms, I really dislike the miscommunication trope, especially when the couple are just acting like idiots and refusing to speak to each other. Being immature is not romantic or sexy!
The music aspect also felt really shallow. I don’t know that Max and Sadie actually liked music — it seemed like they were mostly interested in being famous. There’s an evil, harassing producer in a storyline that was treated way too lightly, and unfortunately the music competition wasn’t the focus of the book.
By the end, I found myself rooting against the couple. They need to spend some time alone before they’re mature enough to date anyone.
This one gets two stars instead of one because of the adorable dog and dog sweaters.
Unfortunately, it didn’t work for me at all. There wasn’t any spark or good banter between Max and Sadie, the main couple. They fought and broke up over and over and over, and always over some misunderstanding or leaping to the worst conclusions.
In romcoms, I really dislike the miscommunication trope, especially when the couple are just acting like idiots and refusing to speak to each other. Being immature is not romantic or sexy!
The music aspect also felt really shallow. I don’t know that Max and Sadie actually liked music — it seemed like they were mostly interested in being famous. There’s an evil, harassing producer in a storyline that was treated way too lightly, and unfortunately the music competition wasn’t the focus of the book.
By the end, I found myself rooting against the couple. They need to spend some time alone before they’re mature enough to date anyone.
This one gets two stars instead of one because of the adorable dog and dog sweaters.