I don't like Lisa Gardner's older books as much as I enjoy her newer books. This one fell flat for me. I did really like the way the killer killed and left clues. I thought that was pretty creative. But Kimberly is by my least favorite of her protagonists and reading a book narrated by her was a struggle. I found it boring and the scenes of them searching dragged on. I thought they'd never stop. This is not one of her better books.